Gear for babies and new parents has changed rapidly in the last decade. The number of choices can feel overwhelming! Since nearly universal insurance coverage for breast pumps started in 2012 under the Affordable Care Act, the number of breast pump brands and styles on the market has skyrocketed. And while having choices is amazing, it can also lead to confusion.
Wondering which pump is right for you? Read on to learn more!
The double electric pump
This style of pump is a tried and true classic that can be plug-in or portable. It uses a durable motor (typically one, but sometimes two) to pump both breasts at the same time. An electric pump uses traditional flanges – the funnel-shaped part of the pump that touches your breast – to form a vacuum seal around your nipple and areola. Features vary widely, but you’ll typically want one with controls to set suction, cycle speed, and toggle between different modes. Many also prefer one with a built-in light, timer, vibration, or set programs.
Examples that have many of these features:
- Spectra S1/S2
- Baby Buddha V2
- Unimom Opera
- Pumpables Genie Advanced
Ovia Tip! A comfortable pumping bra will allow you to be hands-free while using an electric breast pump.
Wearable Pumps
Newest to the scene, wearable pumps are one-piece units where the motor, flanges and tubing are all in one compact package. If you want the benefits of double pumping, you’ll need one pump for each breast. Luckily, most companies sell these as a set of two. Each pump fits against your breast and directly into your bra. You may not need a specialized bra to use your wearable pump, but a bra with easily adjustable straps is always helpful.
Some of the bonuses of a wearable are flexibility in movement, discretion, and useful tech. However, it’s important to be aware of the downsides, too. Wearable motors aren’t designed for durability, and this type of pump doesn’t use traditional flanges, which can make them tricky to fit for some folks. Combined, these two factors can negatively impact milk removal, so a wearable may not promote a healthy milk supply when used regularly. While many wearables have fewer parts to clean, that’s not always the case.
Examples that offer important features at a reasonable price point, include:
- MomCozy Air 1, M5, and S12 pro
- Eufy E10 or S1
- Willow Go
Ovia Tip! Stay in charge — if you forget to charge them, most wearables won’t let you turn them on and use them, even if you’re willing to plug in while using it.
Manual Pumps
Manuals are the original pump! Whether powered by a simple hand crank or silicone suction, these are an essential backup for almost everyone who breastfeeds. In a pinch, these very low-cost pumps can save your comfort and milk because they offer quick and effective milk removal. Note that these pumps allow you can change the flange size to get the most comfortable and effective fit.
Here are some hand-powered pumps to try:
- Medela Harmony
- Lansinoh Manual Breast Pump
Some manual pumps use suction only (no hand crank). Silicone breast pumps suction onto the breast and create tension to help you express milk. Newer brands come in different sizes for more comfort. Check out these different styles below:
- Haakkaa Generation 2 Silicone Breast Pump
- Pump Pod by Save the Milk
Ovia Tip! Silicone breast pumps are often marketed as passive milk collectors (a type of breast pad alternative that collects leakage and letdown when you are not latched on), but they are definitely pumps.
Now what?
Now that you know more than the basics, how do you decide which pump is right for you?
See what’s covered!
Many people start by checking with their insurance to see which brands and styles of pumps are covered. Check online for the different medical devices companies offer. Some insurance companies may give you a flat amount you can spend on any pump. We suggest using your insurance benefit for an electric pump. Although we think everyone should have a manual option at home, the cost of a manual pump is low. It’s also great to add to your baby gift wish list!
How often you pump is a big factor
If you plan to pump regularly, you should seriously consider a double electric pump. You can always purchase a second pump down the road if you pump often and want to have flexibility. Many portable double electric pumps can be used with cups instead of flanges to give you something close to a wearable experience.
If you plan on pumping occasionally, you have the freedom to start with the features you like. Many women will begin with a manual and take time to figure out what will be best. Remember, you can typically use your insurance benefits for a breast pump for a period of time after giving birth.
Do a little homework
Lastly, beware of marketing terms like “hospital grade,” “powerful suction,” or “just like baby.” These don’t mean it’s a great pump, but they are very appealing! Concentrate on specific features and quality manufacturers. But note that even reviews are tricky because they are often paid for, and every person’s pumping needs are different.
Take the first step
Learning about pumping and what works for your body takes time. It’s important to remember that pumps are not one-size-fits-all. If you invest in a pump that isn’t the best match, use what you learn to weed out what you don’t want and need and hopefully find the best option for you.
Ovia Tip! Finding your best flange size, on your own or with the help of an expert, can go a long way toward making your pumping journey successful.
*Ovia does not endorse any specific brand or type of pump. Medical device selection is personal, and there is no guarantee that a specific pump will work for every body.
Reviewed by the Ovia Health Clinical Team
